Here is a lesson in how not to use mobile as a channel.
I just had an experience that proves to me that some companies still don’t get the personal nature of mobile, and the overarching need to ask PERMISSION to engage.
I won’t name the company concerned because they have removed my mobile number from their database and apologised, but the experience is worth sharing as a reminder to companies using mobile as a channel to think very carefully about how they handle private data supplied by customers.
So – a quick overview of the experience.
Last night I received an SMS from the company inviting me to go to a website to look at one of their products. I don’t receive a lot of SMS messages – mostly I communicate via email, twitter, voice or face to face.
Coupled with that, my wife and 3 year old daughter are still in Australia visiting family, and we are using SMS as a communications channel. My daughter has a cold at the moment so when the phone beeped at 8pm last night, it woke me from a jetlag induced sleep (I arrived from Sydney 7am Wednesday morning) and I was expecting it to be a message from my wife.
So not only was I not expecting the SMS, and it was well into the evening, I had no idea how they had grabbed my mobile number. I emailed the company’s feedback email address this morning and also tweeted about the experience. As mentioned above, to their credit they have rectified the situation however, they claim that
“You have provided us your mobile number when you sent a message to request a free xxxxx on 29 August 2008″
I now remember sending in an SMS message to get test a service I had seen on a mobile ad banner – as I do from time to time to look at mobile campaigns I see.
The thing is that at no stage did I ever give this company permission to use my mobile number for any other purpose, so when I did receive the text message – I was quite annoyed.
What this does show is that with mobile, so important to get PERMISSION to continue a relationship – ASK first and then only with permission, send.
I received a follow up email from someone connected to the company saying I had caused “quite a stir” by tweeting my experience, and asking to be pointed to resources outlining mobile best practice (I pointed them to the Mobile Marketing Association who do this so well) – so hats off to them for listening and engaging on this.
So in summary – think about the 3 P’s of mobile – permission, privacy, and preference.
Marketers that adhere to the 3 P’s may find that it leads to fewer messages being sent, but the advertising will be welcome and expected – leading to an increase in sales.
We need to remember mobile is not a broadcast channel – and I can only imagine how many other people received the same SMS last night but did not bother to complain, but now have a negative view of the brand concerned – and will tell their friends etc.
With mobile - it’s personal and we need a new approach to marketing – turning advertising messages into welcome and expected useful pieces of information.
Related posts
12 Comments
Andrew,
Thank you for the wise and inspiring words. My question to you is coming from an MNO perspective; how do you expect the latter to capitalize on mobile advertising? which business model would you envision as the way forward?
Thanks,
Sam
This comment was originally posted on London Calling » the mobile advertising blog
Just viewed your podcast re:Interview Andrew Grill by Klaas Weima …
Ten years is a long time re: Apple/iPhone and now googles approach … doing what IMODE accomplished back then.
This comment was originally posted on London Calling » the mobile advertising blog
Twitter Comment
London Calling: Search works founder goes mobile and launches SOMO [link to post]
– Posted using Chat Catcher
This comment was originally posted on London Calling » the mobile advertising blog
Twitter Comment
London Calling» A snapshot of Mobile Marketing in the UK [link to post]
– Posted using Chat Catcher
This comment was originally posted on London Calling » the mobile advertising blog
Twitter Comment
RT @AndrewGrill: London Calling» A snapshot of Mobile Marketing in the UK [link to post]
– Posted using Chat Catcher
This comment was originally posted on London Calling » the mobile advertising blog
Twitter Comment
RT @carlmartin: RT @AndrewGrill: London Calling» A snapshot of Mobile Marketing in the UK [link to post]
– Posted using Chat Catcher
This comment was originally posted on London Calling » the mobile advertising blog
Twitter Comment
London Calling: A snapshot of Mobile Marketing in the UK [link to post]
– Posted using Chat Catcher
This comment was originally posted on London Calling » the mobile advertising blog
Twitter Comment
Reading: A snapshot of Mobile Marketing in the UK [Andrew Grill]: Yesterday in the Times Newspaper a gre.. [link to post]
– Posted using Chat Catcher
This comment was originally posted on London Calling » the mobile advertising blog
Twitter Comment
mobile marketing update that I missed but you can get here [link to post]
– Posted using Chat Catcher
This comment was originally posted on London Calling » the mobile advertising blog
Thanks for the letting people know about the guide. We are already planning for version two, so if would like to recommend a mobile ad networking, that they believe is in the same league as these nine, we’d love to hear from them.
Much obliged, Andy, mobiThinking.
This comment was originally posted on London Calling » the mobile advertising blog
Twitter Comment
GoMo News magazine showcases mobile thought leadership: Bena Roberts and the team at GoMo news asked thought le.. [link to post]
– Posted using Chat Catcher
This comment was originally posted on London Calling » the mobile advertising blog
was Volkswagen the first one to uses mobile advertising as an advertising strategy? seems like the high paying strategy is slowly getting paid of. Volkswagen now holds the number one spot in vw autoparts sales.
This comment was originally posted on London Calling » the mobile advertising blog